$BGO>l:#F|;R(B

$B;32<=_;R@h@8(B

$BI,FIJ88%(B

1999$BG/(B12$B7n(B12$BF|(B

$B!!(B

$B!X1Q8l650i3X%b%N%0%i%U!&%7%j!<%:!$(B $B1Q8l$N%i%$%F%#%s%0!Y$K$D$$$F(B

$B!!(B

$B!cK\$N35MW$H=j46!d(B

$B$3$NK\$O%i%$%F%#%s%0$rMM!9$JLL$+$i9M;!$7$F$$$k!%Bh0l>O!V%i%$%F%#%s%0$N86M}!W$G$O%i%$%F%#%s%0$H$O2?$+!$$+$i;O$^$C$F(BL2$B%i%$%F%#%s%0;XF3K!$X$N<(:6$,$J$5$l$F$$$k!%BhFs>O!V%i%$%F%#%s%0$NG=NO!&3XNO!W$G$OJl8l!&309q8l$N=q$/G=NO$K$D$$$F1Q8lOCO!V%i%$%F%#%s%0$N65R2p$5$l$F$$$k!%Bh(B4$B>O!V%i%$%F%#%s%0$NB,Dj$HI>2A!W$G$O%i%$%F%#%s%0$N%F%9%H$HI>2A$K$D$$$F=R$Y$i$l$F$$$k!%(B

$B$3$NK\$NFCD'$O%i%$%F%#%s%0$K$D$$$F:,K\E*$JLdBj$r%P%i%s%9$h$/J,$,$D$$$d$5$l$F$$$k%i%$%F%#%s%0$N;XF3K!$G!$B?$/$NNc$,$"$k$3$H$@$H;W$&!%$3$l$i$NNc$O

$B!!(B

$B!cMWLs$H9M;!!d(B

$B$3$N%l%]!<%H$G$O0J2<$N#2E@$re$2$F9M;!$7$?$$!%#1!K(BL2$B%i%$%F(B$B%#%s%0$K$*$1$kF|K\?M$N=q$/G=NO$K$D$$$F(B $B#2!K#1!K$K4XO"$7$F$$$k$,!$<+M31Q:nJ8@.8y$N>r7o$N0l$D$G$"$k!$<+8J5,Dj$K$D$$$F(B

$B!!(B

  1. $BF|K\?M$N=q$/G=NO(B

    2. $B309q8l$r=q$/G=NO$rB,$k$K$O!V8m$j$N$J$$(BT-unit$B!W$,?.Mj@-$rG'$a$i$l$F$$$k$,!$!V309q8l$G=q$/!W%a%+%K%:%`<+BN$,$h$/J,$+$C$F$$$J$$$N$G!$5R4QE*$J;qNA$OK3$7$$!%$7$+$7F|K\?M$N=q$/G=NO$K$D$$$FA4$/O@$8$i$l$J$$$N$G$O$J$/!$6&DL$NFCD'$dLdBjE@$r6qBNE*$K5s$2$J$,$i8D!9$KO@$8$k$3$H$O=PMh$k!%(B

    $BF|K\?M$N=q$/G=NO$r9M$($k$?$a$KF|K\?M$N1Q8lNO$N0lHL?e=`$r!$(BTOEFL$B$N7k(B$B2L$r;29M$K$_$k$H!$F|K\?M$O(BListening Comprehension, Structure and Written Exercise, Reading and Vocabulary$B$N$I$NJ,Ln$K$*$$$F$b@$3&$NJ?6Q0J2<$G$"$k!J(B1976$BG/(B9$B7n(B~1977$BG/(B5$B7n!K!%$^$?(BFarhady(1982)$B$N$J$+$G!$%/%m!<%:!$=q$-69$BL>$N@.@S$O(B12$B%+9q$NCf$G$I$NJ,Ln$bDc$/!$FC$KFI2rNO$O:GDc$@$C$?$H$"$k!%$3$l$i$N7k2L$+$i!$F|K\?M$N=q$/G=NO$O$=$l$[$I9b$/$J$$$3$H$,M=A[$5(B$B$l$k!%(B

    $B$=$l$G$O!V=q$/NO$,l9g!$2?$,LdBj$J$N$@$m$&$+!%$^$:!$=q$/$3$H$OBg$^$+$K!$4pACE*$J1QJ8$NDjCe!$OBJ81QLu!$<+M31Q:nJ8$H$$$&(B3$BCJ3,$r7P$k!J:XF#!J(B1981$B!'(B4$B!K$,!$$=$NEZBf$H$J$k4pACNO!$$D$^$j!V4pACE*$J1QJ8$r$G$-$k$@$1?tB?$/F,$NCf$K;}$A!$$=$l$rI,MW$K1~$8$F=P$7$F$$$1$k!WG=NO$,ITB-$7$F$$$k$3$H$,9M$($i$l$k!%$3$NLdBj$K$D$$$F:n'$N8+D>$7!W$rDs0F$7$F$$$k!%(B

    $B(1982)$B!K!%8lK!$K$D$$$F$OF|K\8l$K$J$$8lK!(B($BNc$($PITDj;l$dA0CV;l(B)$B$d!$F|K\8l$G$"$^$jCm0U$rJ'$o$l$J$$8lK!!JNc$($P?t$N0lCW$d;~@*!K$K4X$9$k8m$j$,B?$+$C$?(B($BC]38(B(1982))$B!%$5$i$K!$0lJ8$rD6$($?J8>O9=@.>e$NLdBj$G$O!$F|K\?M$i$7$$H/A[$G1Q:nJ8$9$k$HHs>o$KJ,$+$jFq$$1Q8l$K$J$C$F$7$^$&!%1Q8l7w$N9qL1$OO@M}E*$JH/A[$r$7!$F|K\?M$O>p=oE*$JH/A[$r$9$k$+$i$G$"$k!%$^$?F|K\?M$OJ8>O$N%9%?%$%k$KBP$9$k0U<1$,Dc$$!%(B($B0J>eMWLs(B)

    $B0J>e$N$3$H$O$b$C$H$b$@$H;W$o$l$k$3$H$,B?$$$N$@$,!$(I"$B=q$/NO$,'$N8+D>$7(I#$B$,Ds0F$5$l$F$$$k$N$,5$$K$J$C$?!%=q$/NO$,'$,M-8z$J$N$@$m$&$+!%;d$K$O$"$kJ8$r@<$K=P$7$F!$$^$k$^$k0E5-$9$k$3$H$,1Q:nJ8NO$N8~>e$KBgJQLr$KN)$D$H$O;W$($J$$!%$D$^$j%7%e%j!<%^%sN.$K@<$K=P$7$F3P$($F$7$^$&$3$H$,$=$N8@8l$r(I"$B=q$/(I#$B$3$H$HD>@\4X78$,$"$k$H$O;W$($J$$$N$G$"$k!%<+J,$N$3$H$r?6$jJV$C$F$_$F$b!$=q$/J8>O$r0E5-$7$?5-21$O$J$/!$$d$O$j$$$m$$$m=q$$$F!$$"$kI=8=$r2?2s$b;H$&$&$A$K<+A3$K3P$($F$$$C$?$h$&$K;W$&(B$B!%(B$B$^$?%7%e%j!<%^%s$N$h$&$JE7:M$OJL$H$7$F!$0lHL$N?M$N0E>'G=NO$K$O8B3&$,$"$k$H;W$o$l$k$+$i!$0E>'$KMj$C$F<+J,$N=R$Y$?$$$3$H$r<+M3$K=R$Y$i$l$k$H$O;W$($J$$!%2f!9$O0E>'$G$-$kNL$h$j$O$k$+$KB?$/$N$3$H$r5-21$+$ie$K=q$$$?I=8=$OL\$H/$J$$$N$G$O$J$$$@$m$&$+!%$3$l$KBP$7!"2?$+=q$-$?$$$3$H(B$B$,(B$B$"$C$F$=$l$r1Q8l$G=q$/>l9g$O!"I,MW$JI=8=$O<+H/E*$K3P$($k$@$m$&!%$@$+$i;d$O=q$/4pACNO$rM\$&$N$O!$0E>'$G$O$J$/$F!$$?$/$5$s1Q8l$G=q$/$3$H$@$H9M$($k!%(B

    $B!!(B

  2. $B<+M31Q:nJ8@.8y$N>r7o(B

$B<+M31Q:nJ8@.8y$N>r7o$O(B3$B$D$"$k!%Bh0l$O=q$/$3$H$X$NF05!$E$1$G$"$k!%6aG/$G$O!$=q$/5;=Q$dJ8K!;XF3$r=E;k$9$k$N$G$O$J$/!$=q$/0UM_$dL\E*!$FbMF$r=E;k$7$?;XF3$X$H=EE@$,0\F0$7$F$$$k!%K\Mh$O<+8J$N46>p!&7P83!&H?1~$rI=8=$9$k$H$$$&=c?h$JI,MW@-$+$i=q$/$N$,K\6Z$@$+$i$G$"$k!J(BZamel, 1976: 74$B!K!%BhFs$O=q$/;v$rDL$7$F<+J,$N9M$(!&7P83(B$B!&4uK>!&46>p$J$I$r<+8JKI1R$9$k$3$H$J$/!$<+M3$KI=8=$G$-$k65<$B!G(BWrite what is important to you.$B!G(B$B$H$$$&$h$&$JBj$K$D$$$F=q$/$?$a$K$O!$<+8JCN3P(B(self-awareness)$B$d2ACM$NL@3N2=(B(values clarification)$B$,I,MW$J$N$G$"$k!%$^$?=q$-I$B$H$$$&self-identity$B$r3+H/$9$kI,MW@-$r<($7$F$$$k!%(B($B0J>eMWLs(B)

$B;d$OFC$KBh;0$N>r7o$K$D$$$F!$(BL2writing$B$r$9$k:]$K$O!$$?$@<+J,$N$3$H$rM}2r$9$l$P$$$$$N$G$O$J$/!$1Q8lOCL1writing$B$G$b(BL2writing$B$G$bI,MW$@$m$&$,!$1Q8l$G=q$/$K$O1Q8l7wE*$J;W9M$,$I$&$7$F$bI,MW$K$J$j!$$=$l$K$h$C$F<+8J5,Dj(B$B$bJQ2=$9$k$N$G$O$J$$$+$H;W$&!%Nc$($P$"$kLdBj$KBP$7$FF|K\8l$G$O(B(1)$B!V(BA$B$@$H;W$o$l$k$,(BB$B$H$$$&2DG=@-$b$"$k!W$H$$$C$?$h$&$K[#Kf$KI=8=$9$k$H$3$m$r!$1Q8l$G$O(B(2)$B!V(BA$B$G$"$k!%$J$<$J$i(BC$B$@$+$i!W$HI=8=$9$k$N$rNI$7$H$5$l$k$@$m$&!%F1$8(BA$B$H$$$&9M$($r;}$C$F$$$F$b!$(B(1)$B$H=q$/$H$-$H(B(2)$B$H=q$/;~$G$O$=$N?M$N9M$($OHyL/$KJQ2=$7$F$$$k!%$^$?!$(BI$B$H$$$&I$B$rI$B$OF|K\8l$G5,Dj$5$l$?(I"$B;d(I#$B$H$OK\Ramanathan & Atkinson(1999)$B$G$O%"%a%j%+$K$*$1$k1Q8l$rBhFs8@8l$H$9$k!J(BESL$B!K3X@8$X$N:nJ8;XF3$K!$%"%a%j%+FH<+$N8D?Me$G!$8D?MESL$B3X@8$,(I"$B?7$7$$<+8J(I#$B$r:n$i$6$k$r$($J$+$C$?$H$$$&0oOC$r>R2p$7!$$=$&$5$;$?%"%a%j%+E*;XF3K!$rHcH=$7$F$$$k(B(Ramanathan & Atkinson(1999) pp55-56)$B!%3N$+$K1Q8l$G:nJ8$9$k$?$a$K$O?7$7$$<+8J$H$^$G$O$$$+$J$/$H$b!$$"$kDxEY<+J,$N;W9MK!$rJQ$($kI,MW$O$"$k$+$b$7$l$J$$$,!$;d$O$=$l$r0BD>$KHs(B$BFq$9$k$N$OE*30$l$@$H$$$&5$$,$9$k!%(BElbow(1999)$B$O(BRamanathan & Atkinson(1999)$B$K1~$(!$H`$i$O(BESL$B3X@8$r:.Mp$5$;$J$$!"$h$jNI$$;XF3K!$rDs0F$7$F$$$J$$$HHcH=$7$F$$$k!J(BElbow (1999) p328$B!K!%$3$NLdBj$O$=$l$[$I4JC1$K2r7h$5$l$J$$$@$m$&!%(B

$B!!(B

$B!!(B

$B;29MJ88%(B

Elbow, P. (1999). Individualism and the Teaching of Writing: Response to Vai Ramanathan

and Dwight Atkinson. Journal of Second Language Writing 8(3), 327-338

Ramanathan, V. & Atkinson, D. (1999). Individualism, Academic Writing, and ESL Writers.

Journal of Second Language Writing 8(1), 45-75